What’s really going on behind Lahaina’s wildfire controversy?

Amidst severe criticism over Lahaina’s wildfire response, Maui County Emergency Management chief, Herman Andaya, stepped down from his position on Thursday. The devastating blaze claimed a tragic 111 lives in the Hawaiian town, leaving many locals questioning Andaya’s decision not to sound the island’s emergency sirens during the crisis.

Maui County Mayor Richard Bissen stated, “Given the gravity of the crisis we are facing, my team and I will be placing someone in this key position as quickly as possible.” The Mayor’s announcement followed a county release confirming Andaya’s resignation, attributed to health reasons.

The controversy escalated when Andaya, during a Wednesday news conference, expressed no regrets for not activating the 121-decibel island-wide siren system. He explained, “The sirens are used primarily for tsunamis…Had we sounded the siren that night, we’re afraid that people would have gone (into the hills)… into the fire.” He further added that many might not have even heard the sirens due to gusty winds and indoor settings.

However, several Lahaina residents argued that the siren could have saved lives. This sentiment, coupled with grievances over perceived slow recovery efforts post the wildfire devastation, prompted Hawaii’s Governor Josh Green to commission an inquiry into the island’s disaster preparedness and response.

Anne Lopez, Hawaii’s Attorney General, announced the appointment of an independent body for the review on Thursday, ensuring “accountability and transparency” throughout the investigation process.

Adding to the urgency surrounding the Lahaina wildfire aftermath, a White House press release disclosed President Joe Biden and First Lady Jill Biden’s upcoming visit to Hawaii next week. Their itinerary includes meetings with survivors, first responders, and federal, state, and local officials on Maui.