Kolkata horror twist: Accused Sanjay Roy changes stance in lie-detection test, truth still elusive!

The main accused in the gruesome Kolkata rape and murder case, Sanjay Roy, has vehemently denied all charges during a polygraph test conducted by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). The test, which took place at Presidency Jail in Kolkata, is part of the CBI’s intensified probe into the rape and murder of a trainee doctor at RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. The case has shocked the city of Kolkata and sparked nationwide outrage, with many calling for justice for the victim.

Accused claims innocence in polygraph test

During the polygraph test, Sanjay Roy maintained his innocence, claiming that he was being framed and had no role in the crime. He alleged that when he arrived at the seminar hall of RG Kar Medical College, the victim was already dead, and he fled the scene out of fear. However, CBI officials reported that his responses during the test were “false and unconvincing,” casting doubt on his claims of innocence. The polygraph test, administered by experts from the Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL) in Delhi, revealed significant inconsistencies in Roy’s statements.

Legal battle heats up over polygraph test procedure

The conduct of the polygraph test has also become a focal point of controversy. Sanjay Roy’s lawyer, Kabita Sarkar, accused the Central Bureau of Investigation of procedural lapses, stating that the defense was not informed about the test schedule, which is a violation of the guidelines set by the National Human Rights Commission. She criticized the CBI for allegedly bypassing legal protocols and infringing on the rights of the accused. The CBI, however, continues to stand by its methods, citing the need for thorough investigation in such a high-profile case.

Multiple suspects undergo lie-detection tests

Alongside Sanjay Roy, six others, including former RG Kar Medical College principal Dr. Sandip Ghosh and four hospital staff members who were on duty the night of the incident, have also undergone polygraph tests. The CBI conducted these tests after noticing discrepancies in their statements during previous interrogations. The CBI aims to determine whether these individuals played any role in the crime or helped cover it up. The involvement of so many suspects has fueled speculation and concern among the public, who are eager for justice in this brutal crime.

Background of the Kolkata rape-murder case

The horrific incident took place on August 9, 2024, when the body of a 31-year-old postgraduate trainee doctor was found in a seminar hall at the state-run RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. Initial investigations led to the arrest of Sanjay Roy, a civic volunteer with the Kolkata Police, based on CCTV footage and evidence, including a Bluetooth device, recovered from the crime scene. The footage showed Roy entering the seminar hall around 4 a.m. on the day the victim’s body was discovered.

While Roy initially confessed to the crime during police interrogation, he later retracted his confession, claiming that he was coerced and is being falsely implicated. This dramatic turnaround has added another layer of complexity to the investigation, which is being closely monitored by both local authorities and the public.

What does this mean for the case?

Experts in criminal law and forensic psychology believe that the results of polygraph tests, although not admissible as direct evidence in court, provide crucial leads and help authorities focus their investigations. The inconsistencies noted in Roy’s responses, as well as those of the other suspects, are likely to guide further interrogations and forensic analysis. The presence of multiple suspects undergoing lie-detection tests also suggests that the crime may involve more than one individual, potentially pointing to a larger conspiracy.

While polygraph tests cannot be the sole basis for prosecution, they serve as an important tool to cross-check statements and identify inconsistencies. In high-profile cases like this, every detail matters, and the results from these tests can push investigators to probe deeper into certain aspects of the case.

Calls for justice and protests continue

The brutal murder and suspected rape of a doctor have ignited protests across Kolkata and other cities, with many in the medical community demanding stronger protection laws for healthcare professionals. The case has highlighted the vulnerability of frontline workers and has led to renewed calls for reforms to ensure their safety. Public sentiment remains high, with many demanding swift justice and accountability.

As the investigation unfolds, all eyes are on the CBI and the judiciary to ensure a fair and thorough examination of the evidence. The next steps in the probe, including potential charges against other suspects and the final report of the polygraph tests, will be critical in determining the outcome of this case.